One of the key factors retarding industrialization has been the insufficient stock of. With 189 member countries, staff from more than 170 countries, and offices in over locations, the world bank group is a unique global partnership. Pdf towards scenariobased impact evaluation of transport. Green infrastructure and low impact development evaluation.
Impact evaluation of the irrigation infrastructure activity. A survey of impact evaluation of infrastructure projects. Impact evaluation is the main means for empirically testing what actually happens when interventions are implemented. However, care must be taken about generalizing from a specific context. Handbook for evaluating infrastructure regulatory systems ashley c. Impact of transport infrastructure investment on regional. Infrastructure workforce and workplace the rand corporation is a nonprofit research. Impact evaluation findings on electricity infrastructure. Project evaluation multicriteria analysis 8 reconsider strategies, programs. The term infrastructure or below the structure is widely used for public works such as water and electric delivery systems, roads, and bridges and, even more generally, to refer to any systems that support society or an organization. The second edition of the impact evaluation in practice handbook is a comprehensive and accessible introduction to impact evaluation for policy makers and development practitioners. Relative to the resources devoted to studying the effectiveness of interventions in health and education, those available from all sources for evaluation of criminal justice programs are. The evaluation of road infrastructure development projects. Impact evaluation investment learning platform ilp.
This book focuses on how school facilities can affect childrens learning outcomes, identifying parameters that can inform the design, implementation, and supervision of future educational infrastructure projects. Introduction henrik hansen, ole winckler andersen and howard white experience from a phased mixedmethods approach to impact evaluation of danida support to rural transport infrastructure in nicaragua eva broegaard, ted freeman and carsten schwensen evaluating the employmentgenerating impact of rural roads in nicaragua john rand. Based on the results of these studies, to develop an evaluation framework, which includes. Understanding the value of transport infrastructure. Infrastructure investment can also raise property values, particularly if these investments bring about improvements in local living standards including shorter commute times and greater proximity to desirable amenities. The effects of infrastructure development on growth and income distribution cesar calderon and luis serven abstract this paper provides an empirical evaluation of the impact of infrastructure development on economic growth and income distribution using a large panel data set encompassing over 100 countries and spanning the years 19602000. Economic impact of infrastructure investment congressional research service summary infrastructure investment has received renewed interest as of late, with both president trump and some members of congress discussing the benefits of such spending. One of the interesting discussions i had this last week was with a world bank consultant trying to think about how to evaluate the impact of largescale infrastructure projects. An impact evaluation of investment in infrastructure.
An evaluation of the fiscal impact of allegheny county mental health court m. A cutoff rule to evaluate the impact of connecting roads on. The evaluation of road infrastructure development projects is an important stage in the development process, as it makes it possible to check upon completion whether the designed infrastructure meets the objectives originally set for it. A quality impact evaluation must present a plausible argument that observed changes in outcome indicators after the project intervention are in fact due to the project attributable and not to other unrelated factors, such as improvements in the local economy or. An impact evaluation of investment in infrastructure semantic scholar. Operational infrastructure plans are seldom a one shot result. The benefit evaluation sheet is a matrix that helps to define and measure an investments contribution. Request pdf impact evaluation of infrastructure interventions the focus on results in development agencies has led to increased focus on impact evaluation to demonstrate the effectiveness of. Project monitoring and evaluation and performance of road projects according to harrison 2008, project monitoring and evaluation involves routine collection and analysis of information to track the progress of a project. Pdf this paper surveys the main lessons from impact evaluations of infrastructure projects, programs and policies relevant to policymakers. Impact evaluation of infrastructure interventions book.
Impact evaluation of development interventions asian. This report evaluates the impacts of irrigation infrastructure rehabilitation implemented under the millennium challenge corporations compact with the republic of armenia. The effects of infrastructure development on growth and. From interviews with dutch planning practitioners, it appeared that the lack of information about strategic policies e. Impact evaluation of infrastructure interventions request pdf. The focus on results in development agencies has led to increased focus on impact evaluation to demonstrate the effectiveness of development.
Pdf a survey of impact evaluations of infrastructure projects. Focus first on those aspects of infrastructure that provide essential services, that is, those involving drinking water. Incorporating gender in impact evaluations meaningfully and practically, bowen 2bc moderator. Impact evaluation is increasingly recognized as an important part of the. The evaluation uses a matched comparison group design to assess the effectiveness of rehabilitating irrigation canals, pumping stations, gravity schemes, drainage systems, and other related irrigation activities. Outline of principles of impact evalation discussion dra.
A scenariobased impact evaluation of rapid rail infrastructure investments on urban form and development in the greater dublin area volume 2 of 2. It is aimed at infrastructure specialists intere sted in an evaluation to signal a commitment to quantitative evidence of impact through their projects. Provision of infrastructure that would provide the transport. This work program was financed by a norwegian trust fund for impact evaluation in infrastructure and by the banknetherlands partnership programs. It supports personal wellbeing and economic growth. Impact evaluation of infrastructure interventions pdf. Impact evaluation of infrastructure interventions pdf,, download ebookee alternative working tips for a much healthier ebook reading.
Choosing an impact evaluation method 187 determining which method to use for a given program 187 how a programs rules of operation can help choose an impact evaluation method 188 a comparison of impact evaluation methods 193 finding the smallest feasible unit of intervention 197 chapter 12. Impact evaluation of infrastructure interventions pdf,, download ebookee alternative working tips for. Handbook for evaluating infrastructure regulatory systems. Accessibility and transport provision have played a key role in shaping the development patterns of major urban areas internationally. Strategies for evaluating the impact of big infrastructure. Use of geographic information system gis in norc infrastructure impact evaluation projects pdf view a webcast of this session read notes from this session pdf delving into development programs effects on women. Impact evaluation population based doortodoor surveys at catchment areas around 18 primary schools in dar es salaam, tanzania secondary data unreliable sample size calculated for 33% reduction baseline and followup data collected from 2 populations. Infrastructure evaluation infrastructure evaluation protocol watch was launched as a clinical decision support tool that was embedded in a bedside patient monitoring system in 2007 protocol watch, 2007. Forming a counterfactual is very difficult in many of these cases, and so the question is what one could think of doing.
Evaluating the impact of infrastructure rehabilitation. Impact evaluation of infrastructure interventions book, 2012. Evaluating the impact of infrastructure rehabilitation projects on household welfare in rural georgia english abstract. Monitoring and evaluation of infrastructure projects has been recognized as an indispensable management function. In recognition of the methodologically challenges involved in the impact evaluation analysis of infrastructure investmentssuch as identifying a valid and reliable dataset hansen et al. Mccs inaugural impact evaluation conference millennium. Benefit evaluation procedure page 4 of 10 procedure detail the benefit evaluation procedure uses the attached benefit evaluation sheet in order to assess investment benefits. International initiative on impact evaluation, 3ie email. While future urban development patterns are subject to fluctuations of the economy and resulting resource decisions. Overview of impact evaluation page 2 an impact evaluation should only be undertaken when its intended use can be clearly identified and when it is likely to be able to produce useful findings, taking into account the availability of resources and the timing of decisions about the programme or policy under investigation. Impact evaluation of infrastructure interventions impact evaluation of infrastructure investments. The book incorporates realworld examples to present practical. What organizational infrastructure and procedures support. An impact evaluation analyses the posi tive or negative.
Finding adequate sources of data 291 kinds of data that are needed 291 using existing quantitative data 294 collecting new survey data 299 chapter 17. Core elements of a welldesigned impact evaluation 320. Impact evaluation investment learning platform ilp food. Transport infrastructure plays a role as a capital input into production and wealth generation. First published in 2011, it has been used widely across the development and academic communities. Purpose of impact evaluation impact evaluation serves both objectives of evaluation. The state of south africas economic infrastructure. Impact evaluation of the irrigation infrastructure. This product was way ahead of its time when clinical decision and electronic health records were in their early stages of adaptation. Tanzania threshold program impact evaluation pdf erin weiser, weiser consulting malawi and zambia threshold program expost evaluations pdf view a webcast of this session read notes from this session pdf rural infrastructure. Aug 28, 2011 one of the interesting discussions i had this last week was with a world bank consultant trying to think about how to evaluate the impact of largescale infrastructure projects.
Impact evaluation of infrastructure projects naoyuki yoshino and victor pontines. Great potential but little impact on inclusive growth key messages a frica must industrialize to end poverty and to generate employment for the 12 million young people who join its labor force every year. Impacts, costeffectiveness, and implications for design, bowen 2bc moderator. It infrastructure is the stuff on which we build and operate it applications. Adequate funding is a prerequisite for sustaining a critical mass of timely and highquality impact evaluations distributed over the criminal justice programs of national and regional policy interest. Transport infrastructure is a critical ingredient in economic development at all levels of income. Considerations and challenges in conducting a baseline study. The economic impact can be transformative, especially at lower levels of income. Pdf a scenariobased impact evaluation of rapid rail.
The support of the prem evaluation unit is gratefully acknowledged. World bank group impact evaluations independent evaluation group. Impact evaluation of infrastructure interventions pdf ebook php. However, to assess the width and intensity of the roadeffect zone, research is needed that. Electric utilitiesgovernment policydeveloping countries. Strategies for evaluating the impact of big infrastructure projects. The authors evaluate the effect of various community level infrastructure rehabilitation projects undertaken in rural georgia on household wellbeing. Intervention community control study designed by amend and cdc. Haughwout, public infrastructure investments, productivity and welfare in fixed geographic areas journal of public economics march 2002 833. The department of performance monitoring and evaluation dpme in the presidency and the development bank of southern africa dbsa collaborate on performance monitoring and evaluation of infrastructure delivery.
1593 955 699 962 789 20 695 843 611 1287 547 1447 1239 307 735 1261 1399 224 1192 382 316 937 846 505 399 258 1231 1449 232 6 1384 1003 611